Two Cases, One Attorney: What Objective Testing Adds to a Personal Injury Claim

An attorney has two clients with nearly identical rear-end collisions. Both have neck pain, headaches and stiffness, and both were treated by good chiropractors. Both MRIs are normal. (This is a hypothetical illustration; real results vary, and no test guarantees an outcome.)

Client A: complaints and a normal MRI

Client A’s file has the doctor’s exam, the treatment notes and a normal MRI. Months later the neck still hurts, but nothing in the file measures why. The adjuster reads “normal MRI,” calls it a soft-tissue strain that should have healed, and values the claim on that basis.

Client B: the same injury, plus objective measurements

Client B’s doctor referred for DMX and DynaROM testing. The DMX report shows abnormal motion at C5-C6, measured against published normal limits, with the finding marked on the images. In a 2020 study, two or more abnormal findings of this kind identified symptomatic whiplash patients with 93% sensitivity and 79% specificity (Freeman 2020). DynaROM documents muscle guarding. A follow-up study at maximum medical improvement shows the abnormal motion is still present, so the treating doctor can explain why the injury is expected to last. The report explains the findings in plain English and cites the AMA Guides’ motion criteria to show how significant they are, without assigning an impairment rating from the DMX study. That accuracy matters: a report that doesn’t overstate is much harder for the defense to attack.

What changes

Client B’s claim is evaluated on documented, measured findings rather than on whether the adjuster believes the client. The attorney can show the adjuster or jury the images and measurements, and the treating doctor can tie the prognosis to them. Because the findings are lasting, Client B’s file also includes a Long-Term Care Report: research-sourced recommendations for future care, priced for Client B’s home ZIP code. Dr. Schmitt can explain the findings at deposition or trial if needed.

The takeaway

The difference between the two files isn’t the injury; it’s the evidence. When the exam suggests ligament injury, objective testing turns “normal MRI, subjective complaints” into measured findings an adjuster can see, and, when the injury lasts, into documented and priced future care.

Call Dr. Schmitt at 443-775-7550 to discuss a case. Sources: Freeman MD et al., Int J Environ Res Public Health 2020;17(5):1693. Knopp R et al., Ann Emerg Med 2001;38(1):31-35. Centeno CJ et al., Pain Physician 2007;10(5):667-672. Tominaga Y et al., BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2006;7:103. Frank CB, J Musculoskelet Neuronal Interact 2004;4(2):199-201. Carroll LJ et al., Spine 2008;33(4S):S83-S92. AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 4th and 5th Editions.
Email
Print

5 Responses

  1. Interesting how the use of Clear DMX’s DMX and DynaROM tests can tip the scales in similar rear‑end cases. Do you think these objective measures could become standard in injury claims?

  2. Interesting how the DMX and DynaROM tests helped differentiate the two similar whiplash cases. Do you think such objective data could become standard in injury evaluations?

    1. Yes. When doctors treating patients involved in MVCs realize how helpful it is to have objective data and how valuable it is for the patient and their attorney, doctors will use this technology more and more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *